Today I wanted to share our experience on the way to MVVM (Model View View Model) pattern in Android project.
When the data binding library was introduced at Google I/O in 2015, it looked very promising technology and very awaited in our team. We have developers who developed in the past Windows applications using .NET framework using MVVM framework. They loved that pattern. And there were good reasons for it:
MVVM gives a clean separation between the UI and the rest of the application. Although it is still possible to bring the business logic in to the UI, because of powerful data binding expressions, but now the framework is on developers side to keep the things separate. And in most cases it is only up to developers to produce a clean code.
it improves test-ability. More code from UI is moved to easy testable View Model classes
it allows to work independently on UI and business parts. And such responsibility delegation becomes more clearer
But until 2015 MVVM was available mostly for Windows application developers, because it turns out that in order to implement MVVM pattern we know it now we need UI markup language and data binding expressions. Without these two components most common patterns developers were left with were MVP(Model–view–presenter) and MVC(Model–view–controller). In the web world things progressed faster, since already from the very beginning the main way how to create the UI was markup language (HTML) and some time later dynamic web emerged and along the way different engines that allowed developers merge data with the markup. But in the desktop and mobile application world markup languages and data bindings emerged only recently. First Microsoft introduced WPF (Windows Presentation Foundation) subsystem with XAML as a part of .NET framework. And later came out Android with its own markup language. About the same time when WPF was announced Microsoft architects Ken Cooper and Ted Peters announced MVVM pattern on their blog. And so MVVM era started in the Windows world, but Android developers had to wait little bit, before they could start to use MVVM framework.
So when the Android data binding (https://developer.android.com/topic/libraries/data-binding/index.html) and Architecture components (https://developer.android.com/topic/libraries/architecture/adding-components.html) were released, we decided to give it a try. Until then we were already striving to separate UI from the rest of the application and therefore we were using MVP pattern in combination with Butter knife (http://jakewharton.github.io/butterknife/). And the first thing we noticed is that we don’t have to write so much boilerplate code to keep the UI and business logic separate. Now instead of Presenter, View interface and Activity that implements the View we wrote very thin Activity and Model View and made slight changes in layout files. So some of the user stories we could write faster. But it was not always the case. When we had to work with more complex views like map view we could not bind the data directly in the layout file, because of the lack of bindings. And so data binding was done in the Activity or Fragment. But from our perspective it was still step forward because most of the views we used had bindings and if they didn’t we could implement simple Binding Adapters. Essentially we started to use data binding in layout markup where it was easy to use it and left the UI processing code in Activity or Fragment where it will have taken a lot of time to find a way how to implement the binding for the layout markup. So for our project MVVM worked out very well, but we should admit that there are projects where it will not bring much advantage. Therefore before you take a decision about the using of MVVM and data binding spend some time to investigate views and available bindings for them you are going to use in a project.